Letter to the Editor: Pregnancy is not a disease
November 20, 2019
Kayla Roesner is the president of Tulane University Right to Life. Renee Trepagnier is a member of TURTL and a Newcomb Scholar.
It is a marvel that one can walk around the great campus of Tulane University and rarely encounter a pregnant student. Out of the 14,062 undergraduates, graduates and professionals on Tulane’s campus, I can count on one hand the number of times I have seen a pregnant student.
Despite their rare sightings, certainly more students experience pregnancy and choose to carry their pregnancy to term, however, why would any pregnant student voluntarily stay in school or carry their pregnancy to term on a campus that exudes hostility and pregnancy stigmatization?
Tulane Students United for Reproductive Justice (SURJ)’s new partnership with the Reproductive Justice Action Collection (ReJAC) brings to light the underlying problem of the university’s stigmatization and lack of resources for pregnant women.
The vocabulary SURJ and its partners use suggests that pregnancy is a disease that is meant to be terminated at first diagnosis. The use of the word “emergency” for emergency contraceptives implies that becoming pregnant is akin to a serious medical issue that must be treated immediately.
The Chemist 4U ad in the original Hullabaloo article illustrates that Plan B and other contraceptives “reduces risk of pregnancy.” Not the risks of pregnancy—such as common, normal complications during pregnancy like high blood pressure and gestational diabetes—but rather the risk of pregnancy, as if pregnancy itself is a hazard or a threat.
This approach to life and pregnancy is disrespectful and degrading. Pregnancy brings into the world a human being, as embryology proves. In the University of Utah Medical School’s online embryology tutorial, the first sentences state: “A human begins life as a fertilized ovum. This single cell gives rise to the millions of cells that form the human body.”
Labeling pregnancy as an emergency implies that the resulting human life is an inconvenience and meaningless in this world.
Imagine the damage these ramifications may produce on Tulane’s campus. This initiative sends the message that one must be young and childless to be educated on Tulane’s campus.
Spread the word! Newcomb-sponsored student org SURJ (Students United for Reproductive Justice) just launched an initiative to offer 24/7 free access to emergency contraception so that @Tulane & @Loyola_NOLA students can focus on school & plan for the future #ThxBirthControl pic.twitter.com/xhCANnvb2o
— Newcomb Institute (@NCITU) November 13, 2019
It suggests that pregnant students on Tulane’s campus are sick, plagued with an incurable disease that prevents them from academic success and social extracurriculars. This mentality and the advertisement propagation create a harsh environment devoid of basic human recognition and value.
Everyone goggles at the cute children on McAlister Drive but shrinks back with horror at the idea of pregnant students in the classroom or library. Pregnancy on campus most likely brings shame and embarrassment because no one wants their pregnancy to be associated with an urgent medical issue.
Students then become peer-pressured to drop out of school when their pregnancy is noticeable, or in unfortunate cases, terminate the fetus’s life through abortion.
While SURJ is attempting to uphold Tulane women’s dignity by providing the Morning After Pill — which is commendable as we should support each other’s dignity — the underlying message becomes “Tulane women are not strong enough or capable enough to continue their educations if they are pregnant.”
This message leads to a disempowering rejection of the Tulane students’ dignity.
As a society, we celebrate women and men who are single parents — those who go back to school and work a full-time job while maintaining a caring home for their children.
Our society criticizes those who do not support private agencies and government programs helping those striving to better themselves, their lives and their children’s lives. Yet, the idea of supporting a pregnant woman who is not married is unthinkable.
This mentality perpetuates the stereotype that women must be supported by someone else to succeed. SURJ’s message fails to express total female empowerment and human dignity despite their hard work to implement this program and their prior work on Tulane’s campus.
Their message unconsciously perpetuates an unwelcoming environment for pregnant women.
Tulane University students, faculty and staff should be working to support women’s dignity and worth no matter their situation. Telling women that they are incapable of succeeding unless they are childless is not the way to support them.
Angry • Nov 29, 2019 at 11:33 pm
Pregnancy IS a medical issue, it IS a risk, it IS a burden emotionally, physically, financially, and realizing that there is a possibility you could’ve gotten pregnant IS an emergency situation if you do not have the resources/capacity to take care of a child, coordinate an adoption, or handle a pregnancy! Wow. I am all for more resources for mothers on campus, everybody should have the resources to succeed here. No one is saying Tulane women aren’t strong enough to handle pregnancy by taking advantage of resources to ensure not getting pregnant!! That is just such a stretch.
Kayla Roesner • Nov 26, 2019 at 6:35 pm
To Jane Deaux,
As one of the writers and the President of TURTL, I apologize we were not able to help you during your time of need. I can assure you, if someone in our group had know we would’ve helped in any capacity we could. We are still willing to help if you are in need. Our goal of this article is for it to not just be rhetoric. TURTL in the past has helped women we were aware of during their pregnancy. We’ve raised funds for diapers and strollers, we have lists of organizations that we know will help women in need and their children. I truly am sorry we were not there in your time of need. TURTL wants to be a resource for the women on our campus. We strive to be a voice for all people. In our meetings we stress the fact that we must recognize the individuals on our campus first. We failed you in this regard. Please feel free to reach out to TURTL if you want through the WaveSync page. I’m happy to talk to you more or, if you want, connect you to other resources.
Jane deaux • Nov 25, 2019 at 5:53 pm
What sanctimonious crap. “Everyone” does not shrink back in horror at the idea of a preggo student on campus…nor do they at real ones in the flesh. I mean, how many people did you interview for this. Because I was one of those seemingly invisible pregnant women on campus. I found out in my 1st trimester that I have a condition that causes severe uncontrollable clotting. I was in and out of the hospital for weeks. Multiple transfusions, my hematocrit teetering at just high enough levels to sustain the pregnancy. It was terrifying. My fetus almost died. My family ended up in technical poverty. And no, your organization did not seem to give a care about me or my baby once she was here…just a whole lot of rhetoric. Thank God for programs like Medicaid and the Nurse Family Partnership. They are truly “pro-life”. Get ready to clutch your pearls babe, because I have news for you. Contraception is an emergency for me. Because *gasp* I have the right to a sex life. And to live after the sex act. I’m not some faceless uterus…I am the people you’re talking about. So please kindly shut up with all your Gilead bs, thank you. P.S. Politically, I’m independent and it sickens me to see people on here slinging around the word “liberal” as if it’s an insulting label that solves everything. These are women’s bodies we’re talking about. Not a check mark on an ID card. Get over yourselves.
anon • Nov 23, 2019 at 11:21 am
This is the worst thing i’ve ever read
Natus • Nov 23, 2019 at 7:48 am
These authors are to be commended for their well-written missive. Most faiths recognize the sanctity of life, and most societies recognize the moral and legal obligation to protect and foster life. Euthanasia, genocide, and murder are crimes, yet perplexingly the elective termination of pregnancy is condoned or even promoted under the guise of health care or personal convenience. Most people sympathize with The Lorax, who tried to protect the trees, yet many scoff at the notion of protecting unborn humans or people on the margins of society. Still, most people have admiration for those who struggle and persevere, who sacrifice for the benefit of others — not for those who choose personal convenience over moral fortitude. These authors courageously speak for the unborn, and they compellingly articulate the precepts of those of us who feel strongly that life is a priceless gift that should be celebrated and protected.
Natus • Nov 23, 2019 at 7:24 am
These authors are to be commended for their well-written missive. Most faiths recognize the sanctity of life, and most societies recognize the moral and legal obligation to protect and foster life. Euthanasia, genocide, and murder are crimes, yet perplexingly the elective termination of pregnancy is condoned or even promoted under the guise of health care or personal convenience. Most people sympathize with The Lorax, who tried to protect the trees, yet many scoff at the notion of protecting unborn humans or people on the margins of society. Still, most people have admiration for those who struggle and persevere, who sacrifice for the benefit of others — not for those who choose personal convenience over moral fortitude. These authors courageously speak for the unborn, and they compellingly articulate the precepts of those of us who feel strongly that life is a priceless gift that should be celebrated and protected.
Harrison Dinsbeer • Nov 23, 2019 at 7:24 am
Imagine the difficulty of being visibly pregnant and trying to go to class normally, esp when people around you are talking about pregnancies like they’re to be avoided. Ouch
Erin • Nov 23, 2019 at 2:33 am
This EC initiative is great for students, especially on a campus that has such high rates of sexual violence. Additionally, if you have any ideas about how Tulane can further provide a reproductive justice framework for pregnant students, you should make sure those proposals are heard. This would have been a great platform to share evidence-based suggestions for changes in school policy that would validate and empower the existence of pregnant people. However, I did not see any specific proposals.
Michael Owens • Nov 23, 2019 at 12:11 am
Wow. These ladies are simply relaying their experiences or the experiences of someone they know. I find it laughable when some of the respondents to this article with tongue-in-cheek , start by saying if this is what the lady wants, then she has no problem with that. Then as predictable, she utters the word “ but.”
Instead of defending the ladies right to complain about being mistreated for her choice to keep the baby, she begins a disgusting belittlement of just how wrong she is.
Typical left wing approach.
If anyone disagrees with the left’s assertion, then you are wrong and must be destroyed for not agreeing with me.
Pathetic.
Pregnant and Proud • Nov 22, 2019 at 1:18 pm
Clearly you guys are virgins and have never been in the position of needing emergency contraception. Just because it’s called emergency contraception doesn’t mean that pregnancy is an urgent medical issue. It is not. I’ve actually never heard anyone call pregnancy an urgent medical issue or disease. Most people get abortions for valid reasons and none of those reasons are because they think it’s a disease. “Unfortunate cases, terminate the fetus’s life through abortion.” You know what’s unfortunate? A woman having to go through a pregnancy carrying her rapists child. Do you know what that does to someone? Now that is what I call unfortunate. You’re making your campus out to be some baby hating place. There are bigger issues to focus on. I hope you’re not a feminist because you clearly do not believe in rights for women.
Allison • Nov 22, 2019 at 1:06 pm
This is a sad excuse for an article. Please find an editor and someone who can educate you on the dangers of blanket statements like the ones you’ve made in this anti-choice and blatantly disrespectful piece of “writing.” I’m donating a dollar to Planned Parenthood for every time I rolled my eyes reading this.
wallace • Nov 22, 2019 at 12:59 pm
the author: there is a group on campus experiencing discrimination…
me: mhmm
author: that feels shame and is undersupported by the administration…
me: YES
author: its pregnant women.
me:
author:
me:
author:
Kameron Kane • Nov 22, 2019 at 12:11 pm
Y’all will take ANY route to ensure that your stance of hating women and wanting to control your own is valid huh? When will you accept that some people with uteruses simply do not want to be pregnant, give birth, or take care of a whole ass child? You say “The use of the word “emergency” for emergency contraceptives implies that becoming pregnant is akin to a serious medical issue that must be treated immediately” and this is entirely true, for me! Pregnancy would be a huge hindrance, for me! If it’s not the same for you, that’s *your* choice. You’re the ones disempowering people; let people decide how to live their own lives and focus on your own.
Also, “in unfortunate cases, terminate the fetus’s life through abortion,” fuck your stigmatizing language. Abortion is a medical procedure safer than child birth. Stop shaming people for simply expressing bodily autonomy, jfc.
Anonymous • Nov 22, 2019 at 7:52 am
Thoughts when reading the comments
Isn’t it amazing how the grammar and amount of respectful language differs so greatly between the Pro Choice and Pro Life arguments? Pro Choice, I would like to encourage you to maybe take a minute to develop thoughtful and non offensive arguments instead of solely using the tactic of targeting the individuals who share a particular view. It amazes me how comments can criticize the arguments posted in this article and yet cannot form well written sentences to share their concerns. Also, if you feel so strongly about this matter, then you should be willing to put the energy into researching both points of view and also putting energy into correcting your writing. Getting into Tulane is difficult, you have to have taken a class on Grammar at some point. Maybe try to employ these things you’ve learned as well as form new ideas instead of reuse the same insults.
On the topic of insults, when scrolling through the comments I noticed that y’all are not very creative in this field. If you are not going to take my advice above, at least spice it up! “Get off you (insert here)” is getting a little old.
Just a reminder to the people who do, however, continue to comment rude attacks on the authors; the fact that these women were confident enough to craft and submit a post like this shows that they are comfortable with themselves. All that your insults are doing is proving their point, that there is no good argument against Pro Life.
Xoxo Pro Life Girl
Tara Nored • Nov 21, 2019 at 11:06 pm
This article deals with challenging topics: health, politics, and ultimately our philosophies of life. Because these are such challenging topics, anger is often a natural reaction. But calling someone a “sad excuse for a human being” is not acceptable- no matter which side it comes from. Resulting to jargon, insulting, and name-calling will never advance a position. It will only polarize. Positive progress requires listening. We are on a college campus- I am proud to be a Tulane student. If there is ever a time or place that epitomizes a willingness to respect and learn from one another, it is here and now. I am proud that the Hullabaloo publishes a diversity of thought- that is the point of free speech and journalism. ‘Anon,’ if you strongly disagree, write an educated article in response and tell everyone why. You have a platform, you have a voice, and I want to what you have to say. That platform is a privilege, so don’t use it to call others ‘ignorant’ or ‘garbage’- that only makes you sound ignorant yourself.
Victoria Van Riper • Nov 21, 2019 at 10:42 pm
Becoming pregnant IS an emergency, a risk, a burden, and inconvenient (to say the least) to people who do not want to be pregnant. Stop shaming people for wanting to have sex for reasons other than reproduction. Stop shaming people for standing up for their bodily autonomy. And stop shaming an organization like SURJ that is providing an AMAZING resource to Tulane students who may otherwise not have the means to obtain it (let alone get pregnant and support a child!). If you are anti-choice, you are anti-woman and anti-human dignity, so get off your high horse.
Stefan Suazo • Nov 21, 2019 at 10:23 pm
ok boomer
girl shutup • Nov 21, 2019 at 8:19 pm
The use of hyperbole in this is amazing!!! my goodness the reach! I love that the hullabaloo is branching into short fictional pieces! So chic! Im loving the way this piece strongly endorses the usage of emergency contraception to avoid pregnancy for whatever reason suits them! It IS human dignity and empowering to choose what they want. Go have sex raw or smth
Janet • Nov 21, 2019 at 7:37 pm
lol. I had a good laugh about this article with my roommate. Since when are pregnant women an oppressed group? It’s not bogus to state that a pregnancy (and baby!) would absolutely ruin my life at the moment. Is it really so wack for women to not want to be pregnant during college, aka their time before “adult life” starts? It’s funny that this is written to be pro-women, but completely misses that by guilting women for not wanting a child in their late teens and early twenties. Just say you want to make life harder for women who have sex and go lol. Hope you find peace and stop judging other women
Anon • Nov 21, 2019 at 5:45 pm
This seems like a very emotional and reactionary article that focuses on a narrow lensed reading of the new emergency contraceptives article & initiative itself.
Nobody thinks pregnancy is a disease just because someone in the Hullabaloo framed it as something to avoid. And no one has any real issues with pregnant women on campus. The reality of the story is that Tulane students are so privileged that they’ve been using contraceptives of all types and have even been getting abortions as often as they need.
The people these emergency contraceptives are for are low income students, sexual assault survivors, and individuals whose families prohibit them from accessing emergency contraceptives in traditional ways.
Get off your pedestal.
anonymous • Nov 21, 2019 at 5:32 pm
I disagree with anon’s comment above–it’s unfair to call this letter ignorant, as the two women who wrote it are clearly informed and educated about what they are advocating. From their perspective, EC is the same as abortion in that it is ended a life that has begun at conception. They believe-and I agree–that the best way to empower women is not to promote EC and abortion, but to teach them that they are strong enough to achieve their goals while pregnant. If they don’t feel ready to take care of a child, adoption is still an option–but they shouldn’t feel pressured into an abortion because of the stigma they are worried about experiencing as a pregnant woman on campus. If Tulane was willing to “empower” pregnant students, then our campus could be very different. I commend the Hullabaloo for publishing this letter, because the pro-life side of Tulane’s campus is extremely misunderstood and often not given a voice. When given the chance to speak, as evidenced by this article, they are extremely respectful and well-informed.
anon • Nov 21, 2019 at 4:13 pm
Pro-“life” people are sad excuses for human beings and a disgrace to women everywhere. Speak up to do something other than degrade women and their choices. This article is garbage.
anon • Nov 21, 2019 at 3:01 pm
this is disgustingly ignorant and anti-choice, and even sadder that it comes from 2 women. we should be doing all we can to empower women to take control of their health and bodies. no one is disputing that pregnancy is a cool and beautiful thing, but it’s also true that not everyone can/wants to be pregnant and we should all the right and ability to take care of ourselves in the best way possible. for many college aged women, that means the ability to not get pregnant. (ps, EC is not the sane as an abortion!) it’s a shame the hullabaloo published this.
Michelle Roesner • Nov 21, 2019 at 2:41 pm
A fun thing called recombination –
Do you know what a locus is? A locus is a unique site on a gene where recombination is able to occur. The interesting part about these sites is that genes from the mother and father can swap when two chromatids are touching at said sites thus creating a completely unique recombinant chromatid (therefore impacting the genotype). In simple terms, the chromatid becomes different and therefore impacts the traits of the individual (their phenotype). The fun thing about all of this is that it happens at conception! That means that a newly conceived organism has a completely unique set of DNA in a very short period of time. As soon as the sperm hits the egg, this process is already going on. Wow! The craziest part? The likelihood of you existing is one in 400 trillion! After hearing those stats and that biological jargon, is convenience still an argument for Pro Choice?
~ A Woman who is Pro Life, Pro Woman, and Pro Human Dignity
Tulane student • Nov 21, 2019 at 11:32 am
To the author, for some people, a pregnancy is an emergency. Even though it is possible to raise a child on campus, for some people, a child is a hinderance to their goals and aspirations.(yes, I said it. You can call me an awful soulless creature now). There is nothing wrong with having a child, but for many young women a child is a large financial and social burden to care for. (Yes, a burden, again I said it!) i respect everyone’s decisions but if there is an organization that wishes to support a woman’s choice to decide when is the best time see wishes to have a child then I don’t see the issue with that