OPINION | Liberal arts education is more conducive to academic success
November 2, 2020
Many business-minded Tulanians and their parents like to talk about the “real world” and its justification of a skills-centered education. If it even exists at all, this mercantile “real world” must be an abomination, a chimera composed of institutions like discrimination, market capitalism, utilitarianism and the U.S. As such, the “real world” could never instill a sense of morality in its citizens.
The skills-centered education is also paternalistic and masculine, in contrast to the androgynous and democratic liberal arts education. Additionally, when students prematurely specialize, whether in a career path or a major, societal norms constrain the entire decision-making process. Pledging allegiance to a single academic sector too early stunts young adults’ development of selfhood and interests. Tulane should be promoting the opposite and dismantling hierarchies learned in primary and secondary school.
It is worth asking at this point why postponing specialization does not simply postpone the definition of hierarchies to a later date. The answer is that a postponed decision is not really a specialization at all.
Exploring and making a decision later in one’s academic career is an informed choice based on qualitative experience in one’s formative years.
Unhurried decision-making that takes place in postgraduate education does not uphold the same limiting structure as deciding during undergraduate university. Already carrying with them a well-rounded intellect from the undergraduate liberal arts education, graduate students receive a subject-based overview through which they may choose a specialty later in their postgraduate academic career.
The Tulane administration ought to implement more stringent science, technology, engineering and mathematics requirements for liberal arts majors and vice versa. This would break down the disconnection between the sects of academia that are arbitrary and harmful to the learning experience of all students.
J.E. • Nov 15, 2020 at 11:22 am
Reply to Not a Business Major 🙁
Clearly you are on financial aid.
-J.E.
Not a Business Major :( • Nov 10, 2020 at 4:33 pm
Wow–this comment section did not past the vibe check. A fellow student saying that the author of this should be deported for his ideas? Are you proud of yourself? Someone saying the author has autism or schizophrenia? Last time I checked, having ideas outside the norm doesn’t make you in any way disabled, and schizophrenia and autism are nothing to make fun of. Find something more original. Your comments only show that you are incapable of producing a coherent counterargument that isn’t based in juvenile insults. Clearly you aren’t learning much in B school.
Robert Chumbley • Nov 5, 2020 at 4:21 pm
@S.H.
I categorically disagree. Bataille was thinking in the right direction when he identified the economy as being centered on excess, sacrifice, and waste. The only activities worth our attention are those which flee from the notion of “meaningful contribution to society” and escape the capitalist enclosure of production. In a word, the academy should serve sublimated desire, not the inculcation of productive skills.
Concerned Tulanese student • Nov 5, 2020 at 4:17 pm
J.E., I thinks schizophrenia isnt such a bad thing. READ D&G!
Student • Nov 5, 2020 at 3:33 pm
Some people don’t have the financial ability to add more classes to the already long list of core distribution requirements. If more requirements were added, as you proposed, it would probably lead to many students’ inability to graduate in four years and complete the major requirements in the field they chose to study. It’s an unfortunate reality in our society as a whole, not just Tulane, that liberal arts fields are seen as impractical. Many simply cannot afford to go here and major in something that provides lower job security. For you to suggest that liberal arts classes are the only ones that foster a more collaborative learning environment and that students aren’t interested in taking them is a broad overgeneralization, and frankly, wrong.
J.E. • Nov 4, 2020 at 11:48 am
Reply to Concerned Tulanese student:
All good business students have schizophrenia.
– J.E.
Concerned Tulanese student • Nov 3, 2020 at 3:27 pm
Whose the crazy writer of this!!! He must has schizophrenia or autism or something.
S.H. • Nov 3, 2020 at 11:39 am
Quite the opposite, Tulane should be bringing back and bringing up majors that have actual jobs associated with them. Bring back the college of engineering and up-level business and pre-professional degrees so that graduates can decrease time to meaningful contribution to society, rather than leeching fuel and money in the process of finding one’s “selfhood and interests”.
Jordan Belfort • Nov 3, 2020 at 8:26 am
You should try reading the Art of the Deal.
– Jordan Belfort
J.E. • Nov 3, 2020 at 7:58 am
I personally think that they should get rid of every school except for the business school.
– J.E.
Student • Nov 3, 2020 at 6:49 am
Who ever wrote this absolute piece of s*** needs to be deported from this country. Communist aren’t welcome in the United States of America.