OPINION | Western world whitewashes, exploits Eastern medicine
February 2, 2022
Eastern medicine has fought for its legitimacy since the rise of Western medicine.
Eastern or Traditional Chinese Medicine is the world’s oldest codified system of medicine, but since the ancient methods of studying medicine did not line up with modern science or Christianity, their practices were voided by the modern world.
Unlike the strict schooling structure of Western medicine, TCM knowledge was passed on through apprenticeships and family members until the 1950s when they took up a more formal training.
It is clear that TCM has evolved to fit in with Western medical practices, as they have begun to conduct clinical trials to test their ancient practices and their effectiveness in a scientific setting. Since 2015, over 1000 clinical trials related to TCM had been registered on clinicaltrials.gov.
However, with each successful trial, the Western world took away the cultural significance of that practice and found a way to profit from it.
Acupuncture is one of the most famous TCM practices, yet, in America, more than 50% of acupuncturists are white, which is more than double the number of Chinese practitioners. The majority of patients that seek out acupuncture therapy are white as well.
These statistics are a result of the constant discrimination against minorities that choose to practice their traditional ways in America. A Chinese woman practicing TCM is seen as backward and uneducated, whereas a white woman practicing TCM is seen as open-minded and worldly even though they both possess the same basis of knowledge.
The only difference lies in their ethnicity.
This phenomenon often leads people of color in America to pursue Western instead of Eastern medicine in order to be taken more seriously by their peers.
This circumstance also applies to patients. A Chinese woman seeking out TCM practices is criticized for not choosing to seek out a western alternative, while a white woman is more likely to be rewarded for being inclusive.
In today’s social media era and the obsession to be unique while fitting in, the whitewashing of TCM has taken off.
A prime example of this is the gua sha trend that swept social media last year. Marketed as an instrument to slim and tone one’s face, gua shas originated in TCM where they are used to alleviate muscle soreness, pain, some illnesses and increase blood flow.
Focused on the highly profitable beauty industry, once companies and influencers caught wind of this tool, it was everywhere.
A majority of white-owned companies turn such ancient practices into disposable forms of aesthetic expression while ignoring the significance of their origins.
This does not just lead to cultural appropriation but also the colonization of minority practices due to the lack of proper accreditation.
TCM is quickly becoming one of the leading alternative medicines practiced in the United States. In light of this, it is important that we support Asian-owned businesses as they choose to share their cultures with us instead of mainstream brands that are commodifying cultural practices.
Bryan Norman • Apr 11, 2022 at 8:13 pm
What if a white person studied under Asian folks, and then became a teacher? Is that OK? Also, I think you’re making some generalizations here. It takes hundreds, if not thousands of hours of clinical training to become a teacher of these practices, such as Qigong. How many unscrupulous capitalistic white people will endure that simply to colonize minority practices? Is this really the case, that they are colonizing practices, or are some folks simply drawn to these healing arts because they actually want to help others? Is it possible that more folks are realizing the importance of traditional healing? I think it’s the latter. In the fervor to call out cultural appropriation, I think articles such as this actually support the toxicity of white supremacy by essentially saying “stay in your lane.”
melissa skopek • Mar 7, 2023 at 1:13 pm
you missed the point of the article, and don’t appear to understand what colonization, or how white supremacy functions/what it really is :/
Alex Menard • Feb 3, 2022 at 11:23 am
I disagree with your statement. “A Chinese woman practicing TCM is seen as backward and uneducated”. I have visited TCM practicioners for over 25 years and I always felt Chinese educated practicioners were great!