Student newspaper serving Tulane University, Uptown New Orleans

The Tulane Hullabaloo

Navigate Left
  • Tulane names Jon Sumrall new head football coach

    Football

    Tulane names Jon Sumrall new head football coach

  • Pro-Palestine and pro-Israel protestors clashed on Freret Street Thursday, Oct. 26, 2023. Three students were assaulted and several were arrested, Tulane said.

    News

    Education department opens federal investigation into Tulane after fight at Israel-Palestine protest

  • Police arrested Thomas Sciortino, 69, on Nov. 25 after a Tulane University police officer saw him walk outside his Magazine Street home, an arrest report and a Tulane University Police Department daily activity log said.

    News

    Man charged after obscenity reported in Tulane library bathroom

  • Jay Pharoah detests racism, turns his story into stand-up

    Arcade

    Jay Pharoah detests racism, turns his story into stand-up

  • Tulane announced the lineup for the New Orleans Book Festival for March 14-16, 2024.

    News

    Tulane announces 2024 Book Fest lineup

  • Graphic by Mylie Bluhm

    Arcade

    Lasting legacy of ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas’

  • Using a rat model, researchers first had to examine the effect of alcohol on the part of the brain called the basolateral amygdala.

    News

    Tulane, LSU research finds new impact of alcohol on stress

  • Quarterback Michael Pratt jogs off the field to meet head coach Willie Fritz in the AAC Championship on Saturday, Dec. 2, 2023. Fritz accepted the head coach job in Houston after the game, and it may have been Pratts last appearance at Yulman Stadium.

    Football

    Tidal shift: Green Wave faces test in post-Fritz era

  • OPINION | Female-dominated liberal arts imperative in male-dominated tech world

    Views

    OPINION | Female-dominated liberal arts imperative in male-dominated tech world

  • Tulane University is headed to the 2023 Military Bowl.

    Football

    Tulane headed to Military Bowl

  • As of Dec. 4, Elf Bars are still being sold at The Boot Store.

    News

    New vape regulations take effect

  • After the loss to SMU, Tulane head football coach Willie Fritz announced his new position as head coach of football the University of Houston.

    Sports

    Tulane searches for new coach post-Fritz

  • I knew this was a special opportunity, new Tulane Athletic Director David Harris said about the return to his home state of Louisiana.

    Sports

    ‘Special opportunity’: New Tulane athletic director returns home

  • Islam Elrabieey, visiting lecturer at Tulane, was once tortured and imprisoned in Egypt for his human rights activism. Now, he’s a prominent human rights activist.

    News

    Islam Elrabieey on Egyptian imprisonment, human rights activism

  • Tulanes undergraduate cadaver lab class is being cut, prompting student concern.

    News

    Students protest elimination of cadaver lab class

Navigate Right
Student newspaper serving Tulane University, Uptown New Orleans

The Tulane Hullabaloo

Student newspaper serving Tulane University, Uptown New Orleans

The Tulane Hullabaloo

flytedesk: Box (In-Story)
flytedesk (In-Story | Box)
flytedesk (Sidebar | Half Page)

OPINION | Tulane’s ranking drops 30 points: Here’s why


On Monday, Sept. 18, U.S. News released their annual Best National University Rankings; Tulane University dropped 29 spots. In 2023, Tulane ranked at No. 44 for the nation’s best universities, while this year, Tulane ranked No. 73. What has caused such a massive drop in rankings in just a year?

U.S. News made their biggest changes to their ranking metrics in decades. This is a response to many who believe their rankings reflect a biased reality. Many institutions like Colorado College have stopped sharing their information with the newspaper because they believe the ranking does not promote diversity and an equitable admissions process. Even an institution like Princeton University, which consistently ranks in the top five, has labeled the ranking as “bizarre, ” unable to create a complete picture.

This year, U.S. News abandoned five of their previous metrics: class size, percentage of students in the top of their high school class, share of faculty with terminal degrees, level of alumni giving and the proportion of the graduates borrowing federal loans. The algorithm now places less importance on financial resources per student: the average cost spent per student on cost of instruction.  Eliminating these metrics affects small private schools such as Tulane, which typically have smaller class sizes and find value in hiring professors with professional degrees. Counterparts who have also fallen in this year include Wake Forest University, Brandeis University and Washington University in St. Louis. 

Furthermore, U.S. News changed their algorithm to place greater emphasis on graduation rates of students who received need-based Federal Pell Grants. The algorithm now considers the percentage of first-generation college students and whether graduates of a university earn more post-grad than people with only a high school degree. The newspaper added four metrics related to research: “citations per publication, field-weighted citation impact, share of publications cited in the top 5% of journals and the share of publications cited in the top 25% of journals.”    

In response to Tulane’s dropped ranking, President Michael A. Fitts said he was “shocked.” Should the Tulane community be shocked by this sudden drop, or is this a wake-up call? 

The main goal of U.S. News’ changed metrics is to create a ranking system that prioritizes equity. Only 8% of Tulane students are awarded Pell Grants, while nationwide, 34% of students receive Pell Grants. 

Diversity on college campuses helps foster a variety of ideas and research when students work with peers with different backgrounds than themselves. Diversity is an important and valid metric for ranking schools. It is imperative that universities value first-generation students and students with lower socioeconomic backgrounds to foster inclusivity and diverse thought on campus. Further, eliminating the metric that ranks schools based on the percentage of graduates with federal loans creates a more equitable algorithm for schools that accept more underprivileged students. This metric had inflated Tulane’s ranking since 69% of students come from families in the top 20% and may not need to rely on loans.

The U.S. News ranking accomplished its goal of creating an algorithm that promotes equity, but it may not truly demonstrate the rigor and strength of small private schools such as Tulane. Further, any dramatic changes in ranking reflect poorly on the reliability of these rankings to accurately determine a school’s stature. Tulane is an excellent school that may not have deserved such a harsh drop in ranking, but it is important that Tulane considers why this has happened. In part, the smaller class size metric has unfairly hurt Tulane’s ranking, but the school certainly does have room for improvement in diversity efforts. 

While the dropped ranking is frustrating to students and faculty who believe their hard work is not being reflected, Tulane should see this dropped ranking as an opportunity rather than an attack. This is an opportunity to reevaluate how Tulane operates and look to the future. Tulane’s motto is Non sibi, sed suis: not for one’s self, but for one’s own. The university prides itself on being an extraordinary academic community that supports each other’s differences, but in order to reach Tulane’s full potential, the university must value and encourage an increase in students of diverse backgrounds, including first-generation students and students with lower socioeconomic backgrounds.

Leave a Comment

Donate to The Tulane Hullabaloo
$0
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Tulane University. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

Donate to The Tulane Hullabaloo
$0
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal